DILEMMA!

okay, so i have been wanting a vintage-y wingback chair for FOREVER, and today on craigslist i found TWO that are both super affordable, and very cute.

however, my friends, there is a problem- one of the wingback chairs, which is a perfect color and a style I like more, has some small tears on it because it is an authentic old wingback. and the other chair looks to be quite gold- possibly too gold to go in our apartment with our new yellow, cream and brown rug.

Here is the rug again:


And here is the first chair:

And here is the second chair:



Aarrgg! What do we do? Ty says it's up to me, but I just can't tell, especially with the rug not here yet. Darn you craigslist and your adorable items that disappear if you wait on them!